Florida Divorce Mediation
In Florida, most divorcing couples are required to attend mediation before going to trial. But just because it’s required doesn’t mean it’s simple, especially when your future is on the line.
It offers a chance to resolve key issues — like property division, parenting plans, and spousal support — with the help of a neutral third-party mediator, outside of a courtroom.
This process is designed to be efficient, cost-effective, and often less stressful than litigation. But without legal guidance, it’s easy to feel overwhelmed or unprepared. It’s important to understand: the mediator is not your lawyer.
Mediators must remain neutral and cannot give legal advice or advocate for either side. To protect your interests, you still need your own mediation lawyer — someone who can advise you, prepare you, and make sure any agreement you reach is fair and enforceable.
At Bernstein Law, we help clients across Florida prepare for and navigate every stage of divorce mediation with personalized, attorney-led support. If you’re considering divorce or need help preparing for a mediation session, call us today at (727) 209-7957 to speak directly with attorney Derek Bernstein.
Is Divorce Mediation Required in Florida?
In most Florida divorce cases, courts require couples to try mediation before moving forward to trial. This step encourages cooperation and helps resolve disputes efficiently.
Mediation typically occurs after filing for divorce but before the final hearing. It helps resolve key issues like custody, support, and property division. However, courts may waive this step in cases involving domestic violence, high conflict, or when mediation is deemed unsafe or unlikely to succeed.
Local courts in St. Petersburg and Pinellas County generally follow these rules but review each case individually. A family law attorney can help you understand if mediation applies to your case and guide you on how to prepare.
What Happens During a Divorce Mediation Session?
How Florida Divorce Mediation Sessions Are Structured
While every case is different, most divorce mediations in Florida follow a general structure designed to keep discussions productive and focused. A typical session may include:
- Opening Remarks by the Mediator – The mediator begins by reviewing the ground rules, confirming that both spouses understand the process, and outlining the goals of the session.
- Initial Statements from Each Party (or their Attorneys) – Each spouse has a chance to express their goals and concerns. In some cases, attorneys may speak on their client’s behalf.
- Issue-by-Issue Negotiation – The mediator guides the discussion through each contested issue — including child custody, parenting time, property division, spousal support, and child support. These topics are typically addressed one at a time to avoid confusion and conflict.
- Private Caucuses (if needed) – If emotions run high or progress stalls, the mediator may separate the parties and speak with each privately. This allows for more candid discussion and strategic problem-solving.
- Drafting a Preliminary Agreement – If the parties reach a consensus on one or more issues, the mediator may prepare a written summary of those agreements. This document is not legally binding until reviewed and signed with attorney support.
- Next Steps – If all issues are resolved, the agreement can be finalized and submitted to the court. If some matters remain unresolved, the case may move forward through the legal system — or continue in a future mediation session.
Key Issues Addressed in Mediation
Most couples use mediation to settle key divorce topics such as:
- Child custody and parenting plans
- Spousal support (alimony)
- Division of property and debts
- Child support arrangements
The goal is to reach agreements that protect your rights and prioritize the well-being of your family.
The Mediator’s Role vs. Your Divorce Attorney’s Role
It’s essential to understand the difference between a mediator and a family law or divorce attorney, especially when your future and family are on the line.
A mediator is a neutral facilitator — not a judge and not your attorney. They guide the conversation, help manage emotions, and keep both parties focused on resolution. But a mediator cannot offer legal advice, advocate for either side, or determine whether a proposed agreement is fair under Florida law.
That’s why you still need a mediation lawyer in your corner.
Your lawyer is your legal advocate. They prepare you before mediation, protect your rights during negotiations, and make sure any agreement you consider is fair, enforceable, and in line with state regulations. Without that legal support, you risk agreeing to terms that may have serious long-term consequences, particularly around finances or parenting.
Simply put, the mediator manages the process but your lawyer protects you throughout it.
Our focus is on creating a document that provides peace of mind and security for both parties, paving the way for a strong and healthy marriage.
How a Mediation Lawyer Helps Before, During, and After Mediation
Before Mediation: Preparing Your Case and Protecting Your Priorities
Your lawyer helps you gather necessary documents, clarify your goals, and develop a clear strategy, setting a strong foundation for effective negotiation.
During Mediation: Real-Time Legal Guidance and Support
During mediation, your lawyer offers advice on your rights, evaluates settlement offers, and guides you through negotiations to protect your interests.
After Mediation: Reviewing Agreements and Finalizing Your Divorce
Once an agreement is reached, your lawyer reviews the terms to ensure fairness and legal soundness, then handles filing the paperwork with the court.
Why Working With a Mediation Lawyer in St. Petersburg Makes a Difference
Local lawyers understand how Pinellas County courts handle divorce mediation, from procedural requirements to common negotiation hurdles. That insight helps you move through the process more efficiently and avoid costly missteps.
A St. Petersburg-based attorney like Derek Bernstein brings this local knowledge to every case. With a dedicated mediation lawyer by your side, you can approach each step with clarity and confidence, knowing your rights and priorities are protected throughout.
When Mediation Isn’t the Right Fit — And What Comes Next
Mediation works well for many couples, but it’s not the right solution in every divorce. In some situations, safety concerns, communication breakdowns, or other serious barriers call for a different legal approach. Knowing when to pivot away from mediation is key to protecting your interests.
Situations Where Mediation May Not Be Appropriate
Some divorce cases involve serious concerns that make mediation unproductive, or even unsafe. In these instances, moving directly to litigation or another legal option may be more appropriate.
- History of abuse or domestic violence: If one spouse feels threatened, the neutral setting of mediation may not provide the protection or fairness needed.
- Power imbalances: When one party controls access to money, information, or legal resources, it can lead to unfair pressure during negotiations.
- Lack of good faith: Mediation requires honesty and cooperation. If one spouse refuses to participate meaningfully or hides assets, the process breaks down.
In such cases, a family law attorney experienced in litigation can step in to protect your rights and explore safer, more effective strategies.
What Happens After a Failed Mediation Attempt
If mediation doesn’t lead to a complete agreement, the divorce case moves forward through the Florida family court system. This next phase may involve:
- Pretrial hearings to narrow down and clarify remaining issues
- Litigation, where a judge decides on unresolved matters like custody or asset division
- Alternative dispute resolution (ADR), such as arbitration or collaborative divorce, depending on the needs of the case
Bernstein Law helps clients transition smoothly from mediation to these next steps, ensuring they stay informed and supported throughout the process.
Legal Alternatives to Mediation
When mediation isn’t an option or doesn’t work, there are still structured, effective ways to resolve your divorce:
- Litigation: Bernstein Law is fully prepared to represent clients in court, presenting a strong case to protect your rights and achieve a fair outcome.
- Collaborative Divorce: This team-based model includes attorneys, financial specialists, and mental health professionals working together to resolve issues respectfully and privately.
Every case is different, and the best path forward depends on your unique circumstances. Having the right legal guidance ensures you’re making informed, strategic choices at every stage.
Money Paid By Insurance Companies
Cases Settled
Recent Testimonials
Knowledgeable, Passionate, & Informative
Derek is very knowledgeable and passionate with his work. He is very good at communicating with his clients and keeping everyone informed. If you want someone in your corner he is your man, he will be there every step of the way.
Awesome Advice!
Mr. Bernstein quickly answered questions even when not retained or could be retained in my specific area. It’s a comfort knowing there are good individuals out there that actually care about families and most of all children’s well being, all through sharing the knowledge gained through many extensive years of education, practice and on hand experience.
Amazing Lawyer
I have consulted Derek multiple times regarding legal advice and he is always on point regarding personal injury cases. Also, an honest individual looking our for his clients best interest
One of the Good Guys
Mr. Bernstein has advised me on the number of business matters, and has proven to be knowledgeable, professional and thorough.
Professional, Courteous & a Winner
Mr. Bernstein has been do PIP Suits for my office over the past few years. He is one of the best I’ve seen at getting these settled quickly. Thanks for your hard work.
ALWAYS the Best!
We utilize Mr. Bernstein for our PIP suit work against insurance companies and we are always treated professionally and their firm always finds us lost money.
Great Lawyer
Provided me with the information I needed and kept answering my questions, even though I thought I was becoming annoying.
Excellent Attorney!
Derek is a very dedicated and hardworking Attorney. Easy to get in touch with as he is technologically very savvy and makes himself available through many different avenues. It helps tremendously that he is also very understanding of clients needs. All around a great guy and a great Attorney.
Thank You
In the short time Mr. Bernstein has been representing my clinic, he has shown himself to be a proven winner. He is professional and courteous in all interactions with my staff and others. His knowledge and acumen has made our business relationship a successful one.
How Bernstein Law Prepares You for Mediation
Navigating divorce mediation without legal guidance can feel overwhelming. At Bernstein Law, we help clients turn uncertainty into clarity through personalized preparation, strategic planning, and compassionate support every step of the way.
Personalized Mediation Strategies Tailored to Your Goals
Every divorce is different. That’s why we take the time to understand your priorities and concerns before mediation begins. Remember, the mediator manages the process, but they are not your legal advocate. That’s where Bernstein Law comes in.
As your divorce lawyer, Derek Bernstein will help you prepare strategically for a mediation, clarify your goals, and walk into mediation with a clear plan. Whether you’re focused on parenting time, financial stability, or a respectful resolution, our legal team ensures your rights remain protected every step of the way.
Legal Guidance That’s Supportive, Clear, and Always in Your Corner
Our team equips you with the knowledge you need to make informed decisions during mediation. We explain your rights, walk you through potential outcomes, and help you evaluate offers in real time, so you’re never left guessing about what’s fair or acceptable.
What Mediation Support Can Do: A Hypothetical Example
Every divorce journey is different, but imagine Michelle, feeling overwhelmed and uncertain as she faced tough decisions about custody and finances. The thought of mediation brought anxiety: How would she protect her children’s best interests? Would she be heard fairly?
Before mediation, Michelle met with a family law attorney who carefully listened to her concerns and explained how the mediation process works. Together, they reviewed her financial documents, discussed her goals, and mapped out a strategy tailored to her family’s needs. This preparation helped Michelle feel more in control and ready for the discussions ahead.
During mediation, her attorney stayed by her side, offering real-time advice and helping her understand each proposal as it arose. This support enabled Michelle to confidently communicate her priorities and make informed decisions, avoiding misunderstandings or rushed agreements.
Instead of prolonged conflict and courtroom battles, Michelle reached a fair, balanced agreement that brought peace of mind.
Though hypothetical, Michelle’s story illustrates how thoughtful preparation and strong legal support can transform mediation into a path toward resolution. Beyond individual guidance, working with a St. Petersburg-based team familiar with local courts and mediation practices, like Bernstein Law, can provide a crucial advantage in navigating the process successfully.
Local Expertise for St. Petersburg Divorce Mediation
Derek Bernstein is a dedicated family law attorney who is highly experienced with the Pinellas County courtsystem and mediation practices. This insight allows him to anticipate challenges, communicate effectively with mediators, and help you navigate the process as efficiently as possible.
Whether you’re approaching mediation with hope or hesitation, Bernstein Law is here to help you prepare thoughtfully and advocate for what matters most.
Call Bernstein Law Before Your Divorce Mediation in Florida
Mediation may be required, but that doesn’t mean you should go in unprepared. At Bernstein Law, we help clients across St. Petersburg protect what matters most — from the first conversation to the final agreement.
Don’t risk giving up more than you have to. Call (727) 209-7957 now to schedule your divorce consultation.
